Companion’s bid with ♠Ax ♡QT9 ♢Kxxxx ♣Kxx is OK
In my ebook, (2♠) 3♢ exhibits 11+H, 3 or fewer hearts, and 5 good diamonds. KTxxx just isn’t actually “good diamonds”, however I’d not blame associate – the favorable vulnerability protects them in opposition to a 18+H LHO on the lookout for a penalty, and the one various is doubling which isn’t very informative.
The chance of three♢ is to make -1 in a component rating when 3♠ makes -1, or to play 5♢-1 as a substitute of 3NT= because of the spade stopper; it sucks, however it isn’t very probably.
Alternatively, double can simply result in catastrophe. As quickly as associate holds 4 hearts, it’s going to be very arduous to keep away from enjoying in hearts. Sure, double doesn’t present 4 hearts in my system, however you haven’t any actual possibility however to move after
- (2♠) X (3♠) 4♡
- (2♠) X (move) 3♡
…and both sequence is absolutely probably.
Your flip: what’s going on?
Step one is to comprehend that one thing is off from the bidding.
The opponents claimed ten spades between them (2♠ exhibits six spades, 4♠ exhibits 4). If that’s appropriate, associate is void, and the opponents’ spade honors are wasted factors.
However… what does associate then have, to say 3♢? Absolutely, with a 0463 or 0364 hand of 12+H, they’d double first; if they’re weak however distributed, say with a 6-5 bicolor, they both do your system’s bicolor bid or double. However perhaps associate is weak in honors, and probably longer in diamonds – perhaps they’ve one thing like ♠- ♡xxx ♢KQJxxxx ♣xxx, give or take a queen.
However then… what’s RHO doing? You don’t have anything in hearts and golf equipment, so that they should have ♠Qxxx ♡AKQx ♢x ♣AKQx, give or take a queen, and they don’t even attempt to examine a slam reverse a spade pre-empt?
One of many following is occurring:
- associate did not double with a strong-ish hand, or they made a giant psych;
- LHO or RHO lied about their spade holding, and they’re in important hazard of happening (the precise recreation);
- RHO has a powerful hand, and is actively stopping their workforce to discover a slam.
We assume case #1 to by no means occur, in any other case your partnership turns into a recreation of second-guessing.
The correct motion in case #3 is certainly to move; any overcall permits RHO to get up and attempt to repair their underbid. (LHO will certainly move, since RHO’s 4♠ might come from a hand with 0H and 4 spades, and 4♠ will make between +1 and +3.)
I undergo you that whereas 5♢ would possibly be the right name in some subset of case #2, it normally just isn’t. The proper name is to move.
The precise hand: the opponents ought to have discovered hearts
I infer from the feedback that the spade-player palms had been (Alice) ♠KQxxxx ♡xxxx ♢- ♣xxx and (Bob) ♠Jx ♡AKxx ♢QJ9x ♣AQJ.
Bob’s bid leads their pair to play 4♠. It seems that it makes so long as hearts break up 3-2 (or the protection fails to search out the ruff, or the membership finesse works), however that may be a reasonably fortunate placement of playing cards: in Bob’s hand, put a jack in hearts as a substitute of that of membership or spades, or transfer a small coronary heart to spades (which might normally be an enchancment!), and it turns into tough. Once more, in your seat, it’s completely not clear that 4♠ makes.
I consider the “ebook” bid for Bob would have been 3NT (18H, a great diamond stopper, common hand). Now, Bob can anticipate that entry to dummy might be tough if the ♠A or an offside Okay♠ is lacking; relying on what the hearts are, 3NT would possibly go down in opposition to a reliable protection. (At any fee, perhaps Alice will overcall 4♠ together with her void.)
If you don’t like 3NT, then Alice and Bob are prone to discover 4♡ (absent a bounce to five♢ from OP, which might be extra defensible now that we all know the opponents have a double match). That is undoubtedly a greater contract: enjoying a 4-4 match is a lot higher for ruffing diamonds than a 6-2 match. The declarer has no actual hassle until the spades break up 4-1 and the defender brief in spades can be brief in hearts.
Companion’s bid with ♠Ax ♡QT9 ♢Kxxxx ♣Kxx is OK
In my ebook, (2♠) 3♢ exhibits 11+H, 3 or fewer hearts, and 5 good diamonds. KTxxx just isn’t actually “good diamonds”, however I’d not blame associate – the favorable vulnerability protects them in opposition to a 18+H LHO on the lookout for a penalty, and the one various is doubling which isn’t very informative.
The chance of three♢ is to make -1 in a component rating when 3♠ makes -1, or to play 5♢-1 as a substitute of 3NT= because of the spade stopper; it sucks, however it isn’t very probably.
Alternatively, double can simply result in catastrophe. As quickly as associate holds 4 hearts, it’s going to be very arduous to keep away from enjoying in hearts. Sure, double doesn’t present 4 hearts in my system, however you haven’t any actual possibility however to move after
- (2♠) X (3♠) 4♡
- (2♠) X (move) 3♡
…and both sequence is absolutely probably.
Your flip: what’s going on?
Step one is to comprehend that one thing is off from the bidding.
The opponents claimed ten spades between them (2♠ exhibits six spades, 4♠ exhibits 4). If that’s appropriate, associate is void, and the opponents’ spade honors are wasted factors.
However… what does associate then have, to say 3♢? Absolutely, with a 0463 or 0364 hand of 12+H, they’d double first; if they’re weak however distributed, say with a 6-5 bicolor, they both do your system’s bicolor bid or double. However perhaps associate is weak in honors, and probably longer in diamonds – perhaps they’ve one thing like ♠- ♡xxx ♢KQJxxxx ♣xxx, give or take a queen.
However then… what’s RHO doing? You don’t have anything in hearts and golf equipment, so that they should have ♠Qxxx ♡AKQx ♢x ♣AKQx, give or take a queen, and they don’t even attempt to examine a slam reverse a spade pre-empt?
One of many following is occurring:
- associate did not double with a strong-ish hand, or they made a giant psych;
- LHO or RHO lied about their spade holding, and they’re in important hazard of happening (the precise recreation);
- RHO has a powerful hand, and is actively stopping their workforce to discover a slam.
We assume case #1 to by no means occur, in any other case your partnership turns into a recreation of second-guessing.
The correct motion in case #3 is certainly to move; any overcall permits RHO to get up and attempt to repair their underbid. (LHO will certainly move, since RHO’s 4♠ might come from a hand with 0H and 4 spades, and 4♠ will make between +1 and +3.)
I undergo you that whereas 5♢ would possibly be the right name in some subset of case #2, it normally just isn’t. The proper name is to move.
The precise hand: the opponents ought to have discovered hearts
I infer from the feedback that the spade-player palms had been (Alice) ♠KQxxxx ♡xxxx ♢- ♣xxx and (Bob) ♠Jx ♡AKxx ♢QJ9x ♣AQJ.
Bob’s bid leads their pair to play 4♠. It seems that it makes so long as hearts break up 3-2 (or the protection fails to search out the ruff, or the membership finesse works), however that may be a reasonably fortunate placement of playing cards: in Bob’s hand, put a jack in hearts as a substitute of that of membership or spades, or transfer a small coronary heart to spades (which might normally be an enchancment!), and it turns into tough. Once more, in your seat, it’s completely not clear that 4♠ makes.
I consider the “ebook” bid for Bob would have been 3NT (18H, a great diamond stopper, common hand). Now, Bob can anticipate that entry to dummy might be tough if the ♠A or an offside Okay♠ is lacking; relying on what the hearts are, 3NT would possibly go down in opposition to a reliable protection. (At any fee, perhaps Alice will overcall 4♠ together with her void.)
If you don’t like 3NT, then Alice and Bob are prone to discover 4♡ (absent a bounce to five♢ from OP, which might be extra defensible now that we all know the opponents have a double match). That is undoubtedly a greater contract: enjoying a 4-4 match is a lot higher for ruffing diamonds than a 6-2 match. The declarer has no actual hassle until the spades break up 4-1 and the defender brief in spades can be brief in hearts.